2021
Nick Edwards – University of North Alabama
2020
Colby Cook – Rhodes College
Jason Eaton – Eastern Michigan University
Blake Hundley – Furman University
Price Warfield – Amherst College
Quantae Hicks – Lindsey Wilson College
Seth Phillips – Lindsey Wilson College
Zach Langford – Western Kentucky University
2019
Devyn Bender – Austin Peay State University
Ford Cooper – East Tennessee State University
Josh Watch – Highland Community College
2018
Bobby Jackson – Murray State University
Caden Patterson – Carson Newman University
Jaden Ramos – Tusculum University
Malik Santiago – Sewanee: University of the South
2017
Brevon Johnson – Austin Peay State University
K’Marhie Dix – Antelope Valley College
2016
D’Vaughn Whitt – Murray State University
Rakavian Poydras – Middle Tennessee State University
2015
Tim Wallace – Trinity College
Mason Gassaway – Georgetown College
Dennis Merriweather – Georgetown College
2014
Bruno Reagan – Vanderbilt University
Derwin Whitt – Peru State University
Colin Malugin – Bethel University
2012
Devon Rodriguez – Union College
Stan Rozar – Western Illinois University
RJ Raikes – Carson Newman University
2011
Alex Lee – University of Mary
Richie Cook – Carson Newman University
Jaleel Jackson – Carson Newman University
Chris Lee – Lindsey Wilson College
2008
Cy Schroeder – Western Kentucky University
Zach Lane – Austin Peay State University
2007
Brad Williams – Austin Peay State University
Isaac Ziolkowski – Austin Peay State University
Steven Biter – Austin Peay State University
Taylor Stanley – University of Tennessee at Martin
2006
Chris Haynes – Austin Peay State University
2005
Lanis Fredrick – Austin Peay State University
2004
Chris Fletcher – Austin Peay State University
Taj Jenkins – Florida A&M University
2001
Mario Merriweather – Bethel University
Kevin Carter – Austin Peay State University
2000
Chris Mosley – Tusculum College
1999
J.P. Hogan- Austin Peay State University
1998
Jay Bailey – Austin Peay State University
1995
DeAunta McAfee – Austin Peay State University
1983
Harry Galbreath – University of Tennessee
1971
Steven Kulback – University of Alabama
Frank Myers – Vanderbilt University
Eddy Shelby – Austin Peay State University
Sammy Thomas – Austin Peay State University
1970
Teddy Quarles – Austin Peay State University
1969
Taylor Stokes – Vanderbilt University
Mike Johnson – Austin Peay State University
1968
John Carney – Vanderbilt University
Gary Shephard – Austin Peay State University
1967 Billy Sykes – Western Kentucky University